On Monday morning, EMI's VP of Sales and Marketing Eric Johnson writes and emails a weekly "news" article to our Sales force. Sometimes it's filled with insiprational and motivating thoughts to energize our Account Managers for the upcoming week. Most often, he imparts some of his vast product knowledge on the group and focuses on a few key products or key features of EMI.
Eric also watches the TV show "Myth Busters" and he just can't help that it sometimes seeps into his work. Well, he must have bought the season 5 DVD last weekend because this week he debunks some of the more common myths about Stainless steel in the industy.
"I'm a fan of ‘Myth Busters'. If you are unfamiliar with it, each week they scientifically investigate the reality or accuracy of some commonly held beliefs. For example, one the other night tested shooting a gun straight up into the air to see where the bullet would come down and if it could kill someone. (The answer was that if it truly is shot straight up the bullet comes down sideways and while it certainly would not feel good to be hit by it, it would not be traveling fast enough to kill you.) It occurred to me we have a lot of myths in our industry also so I thought I'd try busting a few today.
- An all welded, set-up table should cost more than one that ships knocked down (KD). This likely comes from large table manufacturers who import from China and have an up-charge for doing this. The logic is that there is additional labor to assemble and weld a set-up table.
Manufacturers that import tables must get them KD for freight cost reasons. It certainly is less expensive for them to just reship the KD table as they received it than to pull it from the box, assemble it and weld it together. However, for tables manufactured in the US, that does not hold true. A knocked down table uses 4 (or 6 on longer tables) leg sockets. These are relatively expensive. Welding the legs directly to the hat channels eliminates the need for these sockets and the labor costs for welding are about a wash with the cost of the sockets. Similarly, most KD tables today use adjustable undershelf brackets which cost about the same as welding the shelf to the leg. Domestically manufactured tables do NOT cost more to make all welded, set-up (and they are much more structurally sound than any KD table can possibly be).
- A heavier gauge wall shelf will hold more weight than it's thinner counterpart. Many manufactures offer 14GA, 16GA and some 18GA shelves. Logic says that if you are going to place heavy objects (like stacks of plates) of the shelf, you should buy the 14GA shelf.
Technically, this is true. Heavier sheet material IS stronger than thinner sheets. However, the primary determinant of the amount of weight a wall shelf will support is how and to what it is mounted. An 18GA shelf that has its supports screwed to wall studs will hold considerably more weight than a similarly sized 14GA shelf that just has wood screws run into wall board or plaster holding it up. The width of the shelf comes into play also as the leverage on a 16" deep shelf puts more pressure on the mounting than does one that is only 12" deep.
- Drawn bowl sinks are just as strong and long-lasting as fabricated bowl sinks. A competitor (the largest supplier of drawn bowl sinks to the foodservice market) offers a lifetime guarantee on their sink bowls so they must be very sure of their durability, right?
This myth has been fairly well debunked over the years. "Drawing" (creating) the bowl requires stretching of the metal (like blowing up a balloon). I personally have seen a 12" deep 16GA drawn bowl cut apart and measured. The thickness of the metal in the corners was found to be 19GA and 20GA thick (much thinner than the purported 16GA labeling). Another easy way to show the fallacy in this is to point out the placement of the legs. All fabricated bowl sinks put the legs under the corners of the sink bowls as this is where most of the weight is concentrated when the bowl is filled with water. Drawn bowl sinks attach the legs to the deck surrounding the bowl because if they welded them to the corner of the bowl, in use the legs likely would start bending the corners upward.
So how can our competitor offer a lifetime guarantee? It is strictly a marketing ploy. Once you consider the cost (to the owner) to change out a sink (down time, freight, plumbing labor) few ever avail themselves of the guarantee. The cost to the company is minimal compared to the sales advantage the guarantee provides.
That's enough for now (the TV show usually limits itself to two myths per episode)."
What myths would you like to see busted next time? Is there something that you just can't seem to get a straight answer on from your supplier or sales rep? Submit it to our resident "Myth Buster" via the comments below for a chance to be featured in another article soon!